skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Feelings of another generation
We wanted to get a better
picture of what those who lived in the Jewish neighborhood thought and to get
a better contrast of the differences between now and then. So we traveled to
Voorburg where we met Richard Dessaur who was born in the Jewish neighborhood in 1947. He informed us of the struggle that many Jewish families
had to endure when they returned to The Hague after the war between the years of 1945 and 1948. The Dutch Government
was not helpful to these people and shortly after the War some aspects of
the government remained tainted with antisemitism. Many of these Jewish
families including the Dessaur family had to fight to get back in to their own houses,
which had been occupied with squatters and often even collaborators with the Germans (NSB) whilst they were in hiding abroad. Given
such hardships after the War, we felt that Mr. Dessaur might not be comfortable
with the disappearance of the neighborhood or the conversion of the
synagogue, but in fact just like most of the people we later interviewed,
Mr. Dessaur was happy with the conversion as it meant that the building could still
be used as a house of prayer. Similarly he was able to recognize the benefits
of the highly multicultural Chinatown.
To illustrate how The War
effected its victims, Mr. Dessaur told us that if somebody happened to lose their
partner, they’d often remarry someone else who had experienced the same thing. He
stated that this was not out of love, but through understanding of one another,
which highlights not only the physical effects but also the deep psychological
changes that have been created as a consequence of the war. But this also feeds
in to a sense of community, something which was particularly strong in the
Jewish neighborhood. Mr. Dessaur told us that everyone seemed to know everyone,
and this strongly contrasts with our interview with Hanneke Gelderblom, who
lived outside of the Jewish neighborhood and had very little interaction with
it. As a consequence she did not have that sense of community until much later
in life. Mr. Dessaur told us that even today the Jewish community, though
significantly smaller than before, is still very tightly knit.
When we asked him how he felt of
a better understood Jewish neighborhood he didn't care too much for the idea.
Mr. Dessaur understandably felt that there shouldn't necessarily be a better
representation of the Jewish neighborhood but rather of those Jewish
residents of The Hague that had their lives taken from them. However, he felt
that this may have been because he was not actually alive during the holocaust
and therefore only has second hand experience of it, and didn't experience the
changes to the Jewish community. He stated that if we were to ask his mother
whether or not she thinks something should be done to better remember the neighborhood she would strongly support the idea as she experienced the war
for what it really was. According to a sociological study by H. Schuman et al, there are deep psychological differences between experiencing a war first hand and being educated about it through books or parents. A surface level memory from a young age is significantly stronger than the deepest historical understanding of a war. Mr. Dessaur felt that dying without a name for people to
remember is the worst thing that can happen, and something should at least be
done in this regard. He then suggested that perhaps a building with the names
of those who died should be constructed, so they can all be remembered on an
individual level. Perhaps something similar to the war memorials in Ypres and
Amsterdam. He also felt that the use of the internet to list these names could
potentially be even more beneficial as this seems to be something that people
might be more liable to see.
Further reading:
http://www.jstor.org.ezproxy.leidenuniv.nl:2048/stable/pdfplus/2095611.pdf?acceptTC=true&
0 comments:
Post a Comment